Roving Reporters out and about …… Our Supporters comments after going to the Tim Tam meeting
Roving Reporters out and about ……
With some of the Alliance team away on a learning road trip this week we asked our supporters if they could go to the Tim Tam meeting instead.
It took roughly 4 hours for the Councillors to make this decision – so we really want to acknowledge the people who did go to give our group a presence – and thank them for hanging in there for such a long time.
Several of our supporters flagged concerns about the lack of information available when Councillors asked questions about the Tim Tams, and the Trial.
Examples we have been given were:
- Questions were asked about costs to remove and reinstate the road and questions on safety and usage. With many of the Councillors questions there were no clear answers.
- Questions were asked about incident reporting – there was no incident reporting available.
- A camera installed for the Trial had been down for several months – this was to record how many cyclists were using the cycleways and any incidents that happened. Councillors asked why the camera hadn’t been replaced ?
- One supporter had never experienced council staff at a meeting who were supposed to brief the councillors. They commented the staff weren`t prepared and on numerous occasions couldn`t answer straight forward questions put to them. This supporter commented they now know some of the reasons as to why our rates keep going up.
- Councillors were presented with 2 different costs to remove the Tim Tam’s - $1.5M and $300k. Questions were asked about the difference ? The reply – the first figure was a guess estimate and the second figure a current estimate approved by the NZTA. It wasn’t clear to our supporters how the higher figure was put together.
- Questions were asked about when these estimates were prepared and how long they took to complete. The reply – a couple of weeks ago and approx. 1.5 weeks to complete.
A trial has been running for at least 6 months and a rough sketchy alternative estimate, coming up with a $1.5M cost, was done just 2 weeks before presenting the final recommendations ?
Several of our supporters mentioned when it came time to vote Councillors Moeahu, Bublitlz and Bennett played their usual round of questions - taking a relatively easy decision making process to a level of confusion. It was mentioned Councillor George made a simple suggestion to remove the confusion – with the audience applauding the move.
So many people in New Plymouth have had a say about Democracy with these Tim Tam’s. There was the original decision to ignore so many people to put the Tim Tam’s in, but 3 years later, finally listening to the people, to take the Tim Tam’s out.
This week’s Tim Tam removal decision has given a glimmer of hope for Local Democracy for many people …….
Posted: 20 Nov 2026

